Social Security Overpayment Clawback Returns in April 2025 – Know Who’s Still Eligible

Starting April 27, 2025, the Social Security Administration (SSA) is bringing back its full overpayment recovery policy. That means if they overpay you, they can take back 100% of your monthly Social Security benefits until the debt is cleared. Yep—your entire check could be withheld.

This replaces the 10% limit that was introduced in 2024, which aimed to reduce the strain on folks dealing with repayment. But that window’s closing, and many beneficiaries will need to get ready.

Let’s break down exactly what this change means, who it’ll affect, and what you can do if you get hit with an overpayment notice.

Changes

So, what’s actually changing? The table below sums it up:

Topic	Details
Policy Change Date	April 27, 2025
Old Rule (2024–2025)	Max 10% benefit withheld for overpayments
New Rule (2025 Onward)	100% benefit may be withheld until overpayment is repaid
Who’s Affected?	Most Social Security recipients with new overpayments
Who’s Safe?	SSI recipients still capped at 10%
Appeal & Waiver?	Yes—options are available

In short, if you’re not on SSI and get a new overpayment after April 27, your whole benefit check could be paused until it’s paid back.

Impact

This change mainly hits Social Security (SS) beneficiaries—not SSI folks. If your overpayment is flagged after April 27, the SSA can take your entire monthly benefit until the debt is cleared.

But here’s the good news: if your repayment started before this date, you’re locked into the 10% withholding rate. And if you’re on SSI, that 10% cap still applies no matter what.

Here’s how this looks in real life:

Name	Scenario	Withholding
John	Receives overpayment notice in May 2025	100% withheld
Mary	Began repayment in Dec 2024	10% continues
Mark	SSI recipient with new overpayment	10% withheld

Pretty harsh, right? But don’t worry—you still have options.

Overpayments

First off—what even is an overpayment? It’s when the SSA pays you more than they should. This can happen for a bunch of reasons:

• You went back to work but didn’t report it
• You got married or divorced and didn’t tell them
• You received more income or assets than allowed
• The SSA just plain messed up

Even if the mistake isn’t yours, the SSA is legally bound to recover that money. Their goal is to protect the Social Security Trust Fund, after all.

Options

Now, if you get one of these dreaded overpayment letters, don’t panic. You’ve got options, and the sooner you act, the better.

Lower

Can’t afford to lose your whole benefit check? You can ask for a lower withholding rate. The SSA might allow smaller payments if you show that 100% withholding causes financial hardship. You’ll need to provide your income, expenses, and other financial details.

Appeal

Think the SSA made a mistake? You can appeal. You’ve got 60 days from the notice date to file. While your appeal is being reviewed, collections usually pause.

Steps to appeal:

1. Fill out Form SSA-561
2. Submit it online, by mail, or in person
3. Wait for SSA to review the case

Waiver

Can’t afford to repay and it wasn’t your fault? Go for a waiver. If approved, you don’t owe the money at all. The SSA won’t try to collect while your waiver is under review.

Steps for a waiver:

1. Fill out Form SSA-632
2. Include evidence of financial hardship
3. Submit it through your SSA account or local office

This isn’t just about rules—it’s about protecting your income and peace of mind.

While this new policy may hit hard, knowing your rights and acting quickly can save you from losing your benefits entirely. Don’t ignore the notice. Look into your appeal, waiver, and repayment options as soon as possible. And if you’re unsure, don’t be afraid to call the SSA or talk to a benefits advisor. Better safe than sorry.

FAQs